Guide · Refusal reasons

Extraordinary circumstances: what the airline needs to explain

A disruption label does not settle a compensation dispute. Identify the actual event, how it affected your flight, and what the airline did to avoid the resulting disruption.

Last reviewed: 2026-10-11

Check my flight

Assess the event and the measures taken

Article 5(3) of EU261 provides an exception where the airline establishes extraordinary circumstances that could not have been avoided even with all reasonable measures. In C-549/07 Wallentin-Hermann, the Court examined whether an event belongs to normal airline activity and is within actual control.

Start with the airline's written explanation. Ask for dates, the affected aircraft or airport, the connection to your flight and the supporting evidence. A case reference or a generic description is useful for locating the claim, but does not answer these factual questions.

Technical faults require more than an unforeseen label

Normal operating problems are not automatically extraordinary. Wallentin-Hermann discusses technical faults and exceptions such as hidden manufacturing defects affecting flight safety. The technical-fault guide gives a focused evidence request and also explains C-257/14 van der Lans.

Preserve the exact reason the airline gave. If a later answer changes it, request an explanation of the difference. Do not assume every change proves wrongdoing or that every unexpected event must have the same legal result.

Who is striking matters

In the EU ruling C-28/20 Airhelp v SAS, the Court distinguished airline staff action over their own demands from events outside airline control. It also discussed demands that only public authorities can meet. External airport or air traffic control strikes can require a different assessment.

Keep the notice and identify the employer, location, dates and actual operational effect. A news headline saying airport strike may describe several different groups. This EU judgment was delivered after 2020; do not describe it as binding on UK courts. Check the applicable UK guidance for a UK261 case.

The Barcelona Groundforce strike guide shows how to separate a contractor’s notice, its minimum-services period and your own flight evidence. A delayed bag follows a separate claim process.

Weather must be connected to the disruption

Conditions incompatible with safe operation can be relevant to an extraordinary-circumstances explanation. The issue is the effect on your flight, not whether it was raining somewhere on the route. Read the weather refusal checklist to separate an actual restriction from a broad label.

Other departures operating or a calm photograph are prompts for questions rather than conclusive proof. Restrictions may concern another airport, the earlier aircraft rotation, or operational conditions that a passenger cannot see from the terminal.

Check care and expenses separately

The Court's official summary of C-12/11 McDonagh distinguishes the care obligation from fixed compensation in an extraordinary cancellation. A refusal of fixed compensation does not automatically dispose of an expense request.

Use the hotel and meal guide for an itemised request. Keep receipts, airline offers and the reason you had to arrange care yourself. Do not combine several remedies into an unexplained total.

Ask a focused question, then choose the next route

The free refusal paragraph asks for the event and supporting evidence. Add the specific missing point in your case. For example, ask which restriction affected the flight or why an ordinary fault falls within the exception.

If the airline cites a previous sector, use the knock-on delay guide to request the causal timeline.

After the airline answers, assess that evidence alongside your booking and timings. Check route coverage and cancellation notice facts as well. If the dispute remains, follow the correct complaint or dispute-resolution procedure. Owed does not contact the airline or decide the dispute for you.

Check your flight

Free, no account. The result is an estimate: the airline decides whether to pay.

Sources

This page is general information, not legal advice. Owed is self-service software and not a law firm.

Questions about extraordinary circumstances

Does extraordinary circumstances mean all rights disappear?

No. Fixed compensation and care or reimbursement are different remedies. Check each against the applicable conditions and your evidence.

Is every technical problem extraordinary?

No. Ordinary technical problems do not qualify automatically. The nature and origin of the event matter.

Can Owed determine the cause from flight timing data?

Timing data helps with a timeline. It does not by itself establish the cause, operating carrier or doors-open arrival time.

What should I ask the airline for?

Ask it to identify the event, connect it to your flight, explain the measures taken and provide the evidence supporting its refusal.